Skip to main content

fat and happy with labor?


The proper blend of labor, also referred to as crew mix, can make or break a service business. There is a misconception that crew mix is really only about retrofits, projects, and construction teams of workers, certainly not the case.  If the business is not carefully examining the type of work being sold, the contracts being signed, and the general mix of labor (specifically with regards to burden rates) than you will see a disconnect between the cost of your labor and requirements of the service obligation. For purpose of this conversation we will use union terms; apprentice – or those at a lower skill and cost rate, journeyman – higher skills and higher costs.



So you have built a fantastic business over the years, you have very loyal employees and a service crew of let's say 15 people. All of that is great news and congratulations. You may notice that the makeup of your crew over this period of time (x number of years) has moved into a heavily weighted journeymen-based labor crew. Now certainly if your workload justifies that type of labor fantastic, then you are one of the few which have been communicating your labor mix to your salespeople and assisting them in defining what they are hunting. Or… this may not describe you at all; instead you have a loyal group of field workers and your salespeople are shooting anything they can find. So what do you do? Well you certainly don't want to get rid of your loyal and experienced labor, Lord knows that over time these resources are and will become increasingly more precious. You really have a few choices;

  1. review your contracts, working through them systematically X amount per month, and assess your labor mix and potentially raise your contract rates
  2. focus your sales force on selling premium work which can leverage the expertise, and the high labor rate, of your workforce
  3. blend your labor with internal and extra workers allowing the "filter changing" to be done by a third-party subcontractor
  4. do not ever stop recruiting young guns into your workforce to keep your apprentice to journeyman balance



Often times we get mired down in the details and it makes it very difficult for us to manage our businesses. Improper crew mix is essential for the long-term financial growth of any organization and it ripples through contract management, sales leadership, understanding the skill sets of your field workers, and making sure that your workers are working on things they enjoy. We have been blessed in the service business to make good margins which have covered up many of our inefficient behaviors. The future for our business, a labor business running out of skilled and qualified work resources, will need to be very deliberate on the decisions we make for our organizations and employees.



What are your thoughts?



-----

Next post:  is maintenance unimportant and mundane?

-----

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

It's the little details

As overwhelmed Oscar sits in his office, surrounded by piles of overdue work order tickets to review and material orders to procure, his heart yearns to give the customer anything they want, yet the tools at his disposal make it difficult. On this relatively ordinary day Oscar receives a phone call from a marquee customer. This new customer has multiple locations and has asked for just three pieces of information every time a person visits their sites to perform service or maintenance. Oscar gathers his thoughts as he prepares to discuss this seemingly small challenge with reluctant Ruth, the dispatcher who has been with the organization for decades, Ruth can be a bit of a curmudgeon. Oscar does appreciate the inconvenience of gathering unexpected information both for the field worker as well as the back office.   A seemingly great example of ending up between a rock and a hard place. In a world of perfect harmony where all customers, work orders, and requests are exactly...

service an art or a science?

Now that is a question that people have been attempting to answer forever. I have spent the majority of my career trying to move service more towards science than the art. The answer to that statement is, it all depends on the type of service being delivered. For instance, a preventative maintenance is much closer to science as it is clearly defined regarding what actions need to be taken for a desired result. When you look at unscheduled activity, or service calls, levels of troubleshooting are heavily weighted towards being an art.   Service calls take finesse, intuition, experience, knowledge, and attitude all blended together to come up with sometimes magical solutions. When I think about a really good service person, regardless of industry, they are people who have a series of traits that are very consistent. From my experience these traits include curiosity, a deep hunger for understanding, the ability to experiment and have the confidence to make mistakes, solid do...

empathy and service, required?

When you think about the definition of empathy, which is to understand and share feelings of another, you may be curious why this would be included in posts regarding the operation of a service business. When I think about empathy from a service technicians point of view, and one who spent most of his career troubleshooting problems, empathy for me is as strong as one of my previous posts on LSD. The closer a person can get to understanding the initial design intent of a control system or operating environment, the better off they will be in suggesting potential modifications, repairs or updates. I never really thought about the sales side of the equation until my later years, and of course as you can imagine empathy plays a significant role with a salesperson, the closer you get to understanding the customers challenges, the higher the probability of close. Over the years, while interacting with many different service providers, I have discovered that sometimes people just g...